Do wind turbines generate more noise at wind speeds other than 6 m/s and 8 m/s?
Modern pitch-regulated wind turbines exploit the wind better, so that their wind performance is optimised. Even though this a plus for the energy balance, some people worry that wind turbines are relatively noisier at wind speeds outside of the control zone of 6 m/s and 8 m/s. The Danish Environmental Protection Agency asked FORCE Technology to take a closer look.
Measurement of wind turbine noiseSince 1991 in Denmark, noise from wind turbines has been regulated by the Danish Ministry of the Environment’s “Statutory Order on noise from wind turbines” no. 304 (of 14 May 1991), no. 1518 (of 14 December 2006) and no. 1284 (of 15 December 2011).
According to the Danish Ministry of the Environment’s executive orders, noise from wind turbines must be measured at wind speeds of 6 m/s and 8/m. Modern wind turbines are becoming ever more advanced and equipped with many settings so it is possible to optimise the wind turbine(s) according to the actual site in order to produce the most power.
But the increase in settings has led some people to worry that the wind turbine manufacturers and owners set up the wind turbines so that noise is only reduced at 6 m/s and 8 m/s, while the wind turbine generates relatively more noise at other wind speeds. In light of this public concern, the Danish Environmental Protection Agency asked FORCE Technology to take a closer look at the matter.
Data material from 74 measurements of noise emissionWe have since the 80’s performed a high number of measurements of noise from different wind turbines. For this case, we studied their archive of measurements of modern wind turbines, for data including wind speeds other than 6 m/s and 8 m/s and on the basis of the reviewed data, We carried out an overall analysis of noise emissions at the different wind speeds. The final data material covers 74 measurements in the period 2010 – 2013, taken on six different wind turbine types, which represent the types of wind turbines that are most frequently installed in Denmark in recent years.
Conclusion of the noise emission measurementsAfter having thoroughly analysed the large amount of basic data, our conclusion is that there is no reason for concern about increased noise emissions, because there is no evidence of a tendency for the noise to decrease at 6 m/s and 8 m/s.
In general, the data shows that noise from wind turbines increases at wind speeds up to 7 m/s, after which the noise level is either constant or slightly decreasing at higher wind speeds. For noise-reduced wind turbines, there is a large spread in the noise, which is probably because they operated in several different noise settings. In general, the data material indicates that the noise source increases up to a certain wind speed, then the curve flattens out.
“The completed analysis cannot confirm that noise-reduced wind turbines cause significantly greater noise emissions at wind speeds other than 6 m/s and 8 m/s. However, the data material that the analysis is based on is limited and the Danish Environmental Protection Agency will therefore continue to stay focused on the question and follow developments. The conclusion is also included in the answer given to the Danish Parliament’s Environmental Committee,” says Jesper Mogensen, who will also keep an eye on wind turbine noise in the future:
“We have got a good overview and increased our knowledge about wind turbine noise, but naturally it is an area that we will continue to pay attention to in line with the arrival of types of new wind turbines and technology.”